The New York Yankees are facing a significant challenge as veteran infielder DJ LeMahieu has encountered injury setbacks during spring training.
LeMahieu, a three-time All-Star and two-time batting champion, has been a cornerstone of the Yankees’ infield since joining the team in 2019. However, his recent health issues have prompted the organization to explore potential replacements to maintain their competitive edge in the upcoming season.
LeMahieu’s Injury Woes
LeMahieu’s tenure with the Yankees has been marred by injuries in recent seasons. In 2024, he appeared in only 67 games, struggling with various ailments that hindered his performance. His batting average dipped to .196, with zero home runs and a .488 OPS, marking a significant decline from his previous All-Star caliber seasons. As spring training commenced in 2025, hopes were high for a resurgence. However, early reports indicate that LeMahieu has suffered a setback, raising concerns about his availability for the start of the season.
Yankees’ Contingency Plans
In light of LeMahieu’s uncertain status, the Yankees are actively seeking alternatives to bolster their infield. One intriguing option is Dominic Smith, a former top prospect for the New York Mets. Smith’s career has been a rollercoaster, with stints across multiple organizations after being non-tendered by the Mets. However, his recent performances in spring training have caught the Yankees’ attention. Smith has showcased improved hitting and defensive skills, attributing his resurgence to offseason training and adjustments. In back-to-back spring games, he demonstrated power by hitting home runs, signaling a potential revival of his career.
Smith’s Potential Fit with the Yankees
Smith’s versatility and left-handed bat make him an attractive candidate for the Yankees. Primarily a first baseman, he has also logged time in the outfield, providing manager Aaron Boone with flexibility in lineup configurations. With LeMahieu’s injury creating a void, Smith could seize the opportunity to secure a roster spot and contribute significantly. His familiarity with New York’s media landscape, having played for the Mets, could ease his transition into the Yankees’ clubhouse.
Alternative Options and Trade Speculations
Beyond internal options like Smith, the Yankees are reportedly exploring external candidates to reinforce their infield. One name that has surfaced is Josh Harrison, a two-time All-Star and free agent. An MLB scout suggested that Harrison’s experience and defensive prowess could provide stability during LeMahieu’s absence. Additionally, trade rumors have linked the Yankees to players like Matt Chapman, a four-time Gold Glove award winner. Acquiring Chapman would be a blockbuster move, significantly enhancing the Yankees’ defensive capabilities at third base.
Implications for the Yankees’ Season
The uncertainty surrounding LeMahieu’s health poses challenges for the Yankees as they aim to reclaim their dominance in the American League East. His leadership and consistent offensive production have been integral to the team’s success. The potential addition of a former All-Star like Smith or Harrison could mitigate the impact of LeMahieu’s absence. However, integrating new players into the roster requires strategic planning to maintain team chemistry and performance levels.
Looking Ahead
As spring training progresses, the Yankees’ front office will closely monitor LeMahieu’s recovery and evaluate the performances of potential replacements. The decision to sign or trade for an infielder will depend on several factors, including LeMahieu’s prognosis, the availability of targeted players, and the organization’s long-term strategy. Yankees fans eagerly await updates, hopeful that the team will navigate these challenges effectively and embark on a successful 2025 campaign.
